Lawyer Q & A

Submit a Lawyers Question

Submit an Question

Other Lawyers Sites

Site Information

About Us
Contact Me
Privacy Policy


Insane practice in submarine manning

Q.In sort of a related vector, the January, 1999 volume of the "Yale Law Review" has an article concerning the SgtMaj of the Army (Gene McKinney) court-martial, specifically the "good soldier defense" at court-martial. As the group has probably witnessed on several occasions, if a serviceman goes to mast/office hours/article 15 or even a court-martial, but has had a strong service record (especially in batte environments) he will likely be cut a LOT of slack. This article discussed the efficacy of such a policy, and its conclusions are not at all favorable. I guess this might segue with your point that the qualities that are being valued in today's military might not be at all that desirable in the event of a protracted war-time situation. As a further stretch, are the values all that compatible with those desirable in civilian life?

A.The kind of attitude needed by good fighting men makes the politically correct exceeding nervous. This, I suggest, may be why the writer of the Yale Law Journal article about SGTMAJ McKinney (which I have not read) was critical of the great weight the court gave his exemplary service. Politically correct attitudes, I suggest, contribute heavily to the troubles the George Pattons of the world experience in peacetime -- not to mention wartime. In the '50s I was Boat Company Commander of Boat Unit 1 at the Amphibious Base in Coronado, CA. This thread reminds me of the first class boatswains mate of one of my boat platoons (comprised of about 45 sailors who were responsible for 9 LCM-6s). He had stowed away on an airplane when he was a seaman (maybe a PO3) in WESTPAC! They didn't catch him until he got back to CONUS. Nevertheless, he took his punishment (I don't recall what it was), lived it down, and became a very productive petty officer. I suggest that he may not have been allowed to live it down if it had happened today. His attitude about the whole thing was refreshing. He assumed full responsibility and was grateful that he got another chance -- as his later service proved.

Other Questions :

tax attorney vs. planner vs. cpa

The last 2 years I've done my own taxes. This year I will need to figure out a number of issues including some large captial gaines and some unrealized gains that will get hit by the AMT as a result of exercising some stock options. Additiona...

Need advice on selling a house myself ???

I'm selling a house for the first time, and the market is so good for sellers right now that I intend to do it without a real-estate agent. I'd greatly appreciate if anyone could send me or point me towards info about selling your house withou...

out of state executor???

I have been named executor of an estate in Oregon, but I live in Massachusetts. I am also a beneficiary. I know someone in Oregon who would be willing to help sell the two houses and other property involved and would have been willing to be co-...

Real Estate Attorneys

Can anyone speak from experience the advantages or disadvantages of hiring a real estate attorney when buying a house? Can anyone recommend one in the Dallas, Texas areas?We liked our real estate attorney so much, we dumped our real estate agent,...

Revoke Power of Attorney ???

In a situation where two people (X and Y) have powers of attorney for an elderly relative, and X, who's responsible for his banking and other financial affairs has acted improperly, can Y sign a revocation of power of attorney? In this situati...


©2007 Lawyer Q & A All Right Reserved.